Monday, March 31, 2008

Nationalism and Chinese DNA

Here's an incomplete and tentative idea that could, were there a truly significant number of people reading this blog, put me in less than good standing with the Chinese government.

Much like the companies about which Umair Haque is worried, China the country (however you define it: the people, the government, the communities, the vaguely unifying culture) has a DNA problem.

Again, this, like most of my thoughts on China, is tentative, but here are the beginnings of what I'm thinking...

We have riots in Tibet. The glory of the Beijing Olympics are in danger. The Dalai Lama is freaking out. The Chinese government is being obnoxious, imperialist, racist, whatever you want to call it. A dominant, "civilized" society is clashing with an ultimately defenseless and outnumbered indigenous culture. And, of course, it's horribly tragic.

And the tragedy, in my opinion, goes far beyond the beatings and imprisonments. It's a tragedy of a poisoned culture.

In a New York Times article today, there's a woman named Meng Huizhong. She's a 52 year old office worker in Beijing, a main stream member of China's urban middle class and a woman whose political opinions are dangerously extreme. She hates the rioting Tibetans for their lack of appreciation for all that China has done for them, and she's disappointed in the Chinese military for failing to execute them all.

Ms. Meng is a very real part of China. She's the kind of person I met often in Beijing, the kind of person that made every day I spent in that city an adventure. She is someone with whom I would work or study or simply talk, someone with whom I could easily connect, and then, somehow, someone that would suddenly drop something totally radical into the conversation.

I'd hear what she said; I wouldn't know how to respond; and the connection would break. Her unselfconscious, hypnotized love for China would push me out of her world. We would become two species almost, creatures of different DNA.

That nationalism is often a huge part of being Chinese. It's totally normal. Ask someone in Beijing if he'd support an invasion of Taiwan tomorrow. He'd tell you yes in a heartbeat. It's scary, but it's real; it's widespread; and it's powerful.

Look at the Tibet situation. Look at Han Chinese reactions. Look at Ms. Meng. Blindness. Anger. Hatred. Inhumanity.

But Ms. Meng is human, and our hypothetical Taiwan invader is human. They connect as well as anyone else. They think similarly. They act similarly. They respond to the same inputs and incentives. But they've adjusted to a different world, evolved tiny differences in their DNA. They are resourceful people coping with the strange realities of the societal conditions under which they live. And those conditions, those constraints, those fleeting and nebulous components of the thought environment in which they've been soaking all their lives, have and produce DNA that, to me, seems bad.

So there you go. That's my rave for the moment. Maybe DNA's the wrong metaphor. Maybe it's my non-nationalistic DNA that's bad. Or maybe it's just time for me to go to sleep and think about this some more tomorrow.

Note: Find a possible cure for bad DNA here and a possible cure for nationalism here. Thurman should be pretty self-explanatory. Abani might be a little trickier. Listen for this line, though, and see where it takes you: "The cause of all our trouble is the belief in an essential pure identity: religious, ethnic, historical, ideological."

Update (Apr 1): Emily Parker at the Wall Street Journal isn't as distraught over Chinese nationalism as I am, but she does know it's a worry.


Sarah said...

DNA is definitely a bad metaphor. DNA implies that something is hard wired into people's genetic code, like they were born that way, like it's an inherent difference. If nationalism is cultural and in large part created and supported by the government in their effort to maintain legitimacy, than it is nurture and not nature making DNA a particularly bad metaphorical choice

Jake de Grazia said...

Totally dangerous and stupid metaphor. You're right.

I used it because I wanted to get at the MAPPING thing. I wanted to conjure a self-perpetuating cultural code.

Our bodies build themselves, molecularly, according to the instruction manual that is DNA. A Chinese baby becomes a Chinese adult according to the instruction manual that is cultural DNA.

And the DNA builds copies of itself (stacks of instruction manuals) into everything it produces.

And I think the government propaganda machine is a product of the DNA, not its cause (it's a self-perpetuating product, though, of course). I think the DNA has roots in the Confucian tradition, in imperial glory, in historical humiliation. The CCP is not steering Chinese culture. History and cultural DNA created the CCP, and the CCP is operating according to the cultural blueprint.

Regardless, though, it's a worry of a metaphor. I was insensitively oblivious to that fact that I was using a genetic metaphor and dealing with something related to race and ethnicity.

I definitely don't mean to imply that Han Chinese have poison in their genes.

I want to say that there's an historically-rooted self-perpetuating poison in the culture, and I think nationalism is either the poison itself or the way the poison manifests itself or something.

But, once again, I'm struggling to express my feelings about China. I'm conflicted and frustrated. I have so much irrational love for everything over there, but, at the same time, the stifling nature of the culture makes me want to kidnap every Chinese baby and carry them far far away from their parents and teachers.

But I guess it's possible to get equally worked up about all cultures when you look at them as huge generalized cultures. I mean the generalized US culture is a pretty big worry too. And there are beautifully nuanced cultural pockets in China of course. Not everyone we know over there carries the nationalism poison.

Anyway, there's my second try at sort of explaining myself (I accidentally erased the first long comment I wrote). Thanks for calling me on it. I threw these thoughts up here hoping people would set me straight. You've started the process.

Peace. Love.

den be said...

Dịch vụ chuyển phát nhanh ở tphcm ngày ngày càng phát triển góp phần nâng cao dịch vụ mua bán đặc biệt mua bán online. Nên các chuyển phát nhanh thành phố hồ chí minh luôn được phát triển nâng cao nhu cầu phục vụ công ty doanh nghiệp. Dịch vụ chuyển phát nhanh của Công ty Proship đã được nhiều tổ chức, doanh nghiệp, cá nhân yêu mến, tin cậy và hợp tác lâu dài. Trong quá trình xây dựng và phát triển, chúng tôi công ty chuyển phát nhanh hcm là hiện thân cho tinh thần trách nhiệm và trung thực, dịch vụ chu đáo và nhanh chóng. Tại thị trường Tphcm, Proship được đánh giá là một trong những Công ty Chuyển phát nhanh làm ăn có hiệu quả, uy tín, có sức phát triển và dành được nhiều cảm mến. Chuyên cung cấp các dịch vụ chuyển hàng đi sài gòn .Ngoài dịch vụ nhanh chóng, chu đáo và giá cả hợp lý thì Proship cũng có nhiều chương trình khuyến mãi cho các khách hàng tại Sài Gòn. Nên nếu bạn là cá nhân hay công ty doanh nghiệp đang có nhu cầu sử dụng chuyển phát nhanh đi sài gòn hãy liên hệ với chúng tôi công ty Proship. Với những uy tín vốn có của doanh nghiệp, chuyển phát Proship nhận vận chuyển các loại hàng hóa và bưu phẩm theo yêu cầu của khách hàng. Với thời gian 1 ngày duy nhất cho quá trình vận chuyển hàng từ các tỉnh thành trên cả nước và chuyển phát nhanh ở sài gòn , chúng tôi sẽ nhận hàng của quý khách tại văn phòng hoặc tại nhà riêng, công ty sau đó sẽ kết nối vào Đà Nẵng và phát tận tay người nhận theo địa chỉ ghi trên bưu kiện. Nếu bạn có nhu cầu sử dụng dịch vụ ship hàng Nhật chúng tôi đáp ứng cho bạn với chi phí và giá phải chăn nhất.Hay tham quan bruno xem nhiều mặt hàng thời trang khác.

Vương Nguyễn said...

Cách mua hàng
Amazon như thế nào
Dịch vụ mua hàng
amazon tại thành phố Hồ Chí Minh
Cách mua hàng trên Amazon như thế nào
Order hàng Mỹ tại Việt Nam
Mua hàng trên Amazon tại Hà Nội
chuyển nhà trọn gói phan nguyễn express
dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói hồ chí minh
chuyển văn phòng trọn gói hồ chí minh

Tổng Hợp said...

Order hàng Mỹ
Mua hộ hàng Mỹ
Mua hàng trên Amazon
Thuốc tăng chiều cao
Cách tăng chiều cao
Thuốc tăng chiều cao
Thực phẩm chức năng tăng chiều cao

Tổng Hợp said...

in túi giấy giá rẻ
in hộp giấy giá rẻ
bài tập tăng chiều cao
bí quyết tăng chiều cao
cách tăng chiều cao
cách phát triển chiều cao
chai lọ mỹ phẩm
chai lọ mỹ phẩm

Tổng Hợp said...

iq test online free with results
accurate iq test online
iq test online free for kids
iq test online
in túi giấy

10 Top said...

ship hàng Mỹ giá rẻ